S1E2 The Religion We Grew Up In: What We Took, What We Left
Every faith leaves fingerprints: some beautiful, some bruising.
In this episode, we gently unpack the complex relationship many of us have with the religion we grew up in. For those who’ve stepped away from belief, but still feel its echoes, this conversation offers space to reflect, honour, grieve, and rebuild.
We explore:
- How religion shaped our identity, morality, and relationships
- What we chose to carry with us after leaving and why
- What we had to unlearn to reclaim our own sense of self
- How to hold both reverence and rejection in the same hand
- A humanist lens for meaning-making, purpose, and moral clarity
This isn’t about throwing everything away.
It’s about choosing with intention.
And finding new ways to live good, walk good, without guilt, fear, or dogma.
💭 Reflection Invitation
- What parts of your upbringing still live in you?
- What have you lovingly released?
- How do you want to define your moral and spiritual compass now?
📖 Try the practice:
Write a “thank you and goodbye” letter to your childhood religion: what it gave, what it took, and what you’re reclaiming.
🔗 Mentioned or Referenced
- Quote: All About Love: New Visions (2000). bell hooks. “Love is an action, never simply a feeling.”
- The shift from divine purpose to human-centered meaning-making
🎧 Subscribe & Stay Connected
If this episode resonated, share it with someone who’s also navigating life after faith.
Send in your reflections or voice notes for future episodes, anonymously or with your name. I’d love to hear your story.
👉 Follow the podcast, leave a review, and keep walking with us.
Because the path is still good, even if it’s not the one you started on.
Transcript
Welcome back to Live Good.
2
:Walk Good.
3
:the podcast about living
well without religion.
4
:I'm Bianca, your host, inviting you
into honest human conversations about
5
:ethics, meaning, and joy beyond the pews.
6
:Whether you've left faith, are
questioning, or you're just
7
:curious, you're welcome here.
8
:Let's get into it.
9
:This week, we're talking about
the religion we grew up in.
10
:Not to tear it apart and not to
worship at its alter either, but to sit
11
:with it and ask what did it give us?
12
:What did we carry forward?
13
:And what did we have to leave
behind just to be able to breathe?
14
:For me, I still remember Sunday mornings.
15
:I remember the shiny, tight
shoes, well-pressed clothes, my
16
:own little bible that never quite
got rid of that new book smell.
17
:I remember my mother's voice beside me in
the pews as she sang old hymns that she
18
:loved, her voice filling with emotion.
19
:There was a lot of love in that
space and also a kind of quiet fear.
20
:A fear of asking too many questions,
of wanting too much, of being too much.
21
:And yet, I know, and I
acknowledge, that faith shaped me.
22
:Even now, long after I stopped
believing, I can still feel
23
:its fingerprints in my life.
24
:Some of them are beautiful
and some of them not so much.
25
:Today's episode is for anyone who's
walked away from religion but never quite
26
:stopped feeling its weight or its warmth.
27
:We're going to explore how it is that
we hold both things at the same time.
28
:How do we honor our roots
without choking on the branches?
29
:How do we grieve and grow at once?
30
:How do we walk forward without
pretending the past never happened?
31
:Because leaving a belief system
doesn't always mean leaving
32
:behind everything it gave us.
33
:Let's walk through it together.
34
:So before we talk about what we kept or
what we left, I want to take a moment
35
:to really look at what we were given,
because none of us started from nowhere.
36
:We were shaped, we inherited things.
37
:Let's start there.
38
:I grew up in Jamaica, which
is to say I grew up in church.
39
:Most of us did.
40
:Not just on Sundays though.
41
:Church was in the music we
heard, the language we used, the
42
:food we blessed before we ate.
43
:It was stitched into school mornings
with group devotions and prayers.
44
:It's tucked into every wedding, every
funeral, every holiday, every good
45
:morning that ended with God bless you.
46
:For my family, it was mostly
Anglican, so robes, incense, pews.
47
:I went to Sunday school as a child.
48
:I joined the youth group and choir.
49
:As I got older, I went to confirmation
classes so that I could finally
50
:take communion with the grownups.
51
:But the deeper current isn't really
about the denomination because
52
:regardless of which one you grew up in.
53
:It was about expectation.
54
:It was about what was normal.
55
:God was the default.
56
:Faith was assumed and belief
was pretty much just baked in.
57
:Luckily for me, I didn't grow up in
what you'd call a fire and brimstone
58
:home, but there was still a quiet
pressure, a pressure to be good.
59
:Follow the rules.
60
:Don't ask too many questions.
61
:There were stories you
weren't supposed to ask about.
62
:There were things you weren't
supposed to say, loud desires
63
:you're not supposed to have.
64
:And yet, I find when I look back,
there were parts that felt like home.
65
:There was rhythm in the ritual.
66
:There was something grounding
in the hymns and the silence.
67
:And the sense of being part of
something older than you, something
68
:bigger than you church was community.
69
:There are still people in my wider network
who I have just always known from church.
70
:Church was where you learned
how to be seen, and sometimes
71
:where you learned how to hide.
72
:But honestly for a lot of us growing
up in the Caribbean, religion wasn't
73
:just belief, it was structure.
74
:It shaped your weak, your values,
your boundaries told you who you were
75
:and who you weren't allowed to be.
76
:And now as I encounter and I speak to
more and more people who have stepped
77
:away from traditional religion.
78
:Whether gently or with anger, I realize
there's a complexity that we all carry.
79
:Some of us remember the joy.
80
:Some still flinch at the shame, and
some of us are still untangling.
81
:What parts of it came from
love and what came from fear?
82
:So I invite you, maybe take a moment right
now and think back to what you grew up in.
83
:What faith or framework shaped your
early sense of right and wrong?
84
:Was it a sense of comfort,
a source of control?
85
:Did it help you feel held or
did it make you feel small?
86
:There really is no right answer.
87
:This is just a chance to notice
what's still with you, which parts
88
:still echo and what still stings.
89
:We're not here to judge your upbringing
or your family, or your past self, but
90
:the aim is for you to see it clearly,
name it, and make space for it without
91
:letting it take up the whole room.
92
:Because before we talk about what
we kept or what we left behind, we
93
:have to name what we were handed.
94
:Not just the beliefs, but the
silences, the rituals and the rules.
95
:Not just a God we were told to
follow, but the fear that we
96
:were taught to carry with us.
97
:We inherit more than just the faith.
98
:We inherit the frameworks, the ways
of seeing ourselves, the ways of
99
:belonging, or not ways of measuring our
worth or bodies or questions or joy.
100
:And until we can name
it, it still owns us.
101
:It still lives in a background
shaping how we walk through the world.
102
:So this isn't just about looking back,
it's about tracing those outlines of
103
:what shaped us so we can decide with care
what still deserves a place in our lives.
104
:Of course, our story doesn't
go straight to the ending with
105
:walking away because this is not
just about rejection of that past.
106
:It's also about remembering the
parts that stayed with us, because
107
:sometimes even after the belief
fades, something beautiful remains.
108
:So let's talk about
what we carried forward.
109
:Here's the thing that surprised me.
110
:When I first started drifting from
church, I thought I had to let go of
111
:everything, all or nothing, in or out.
112
:And for a while that's how it felt.
113
:Like I was walking away from a
house I had lived in my whole life,
114
:turning my back on every room, even
the ones where the light came in.
115
:But over time I realized something softer.
116
:I hadn't left everything behind.
117
:Some things followed me out.
118
:Some things I chose to carry.
119
:Like rhythm.
120
:Church gave me rhythm, not the rhythm
of clapping and dancing because my
121
:church, the Anglican Church of 30
years ago was not a clapping and
122
:dancing kind of church, God forbid,
but there was a rhythm to the routine.
123
:Sunday mornings as a marker, quiet
pauses for prayer during service,
124
:the marking of time through rituals.
125
:And even now, though I stopped
attending church decades ago, I find
126
:comfort in rhythm and structure.
127
:The idea of pausing, of
naming, of returning.
128
:I've just changed the container
and my rituals are different
129
:now, but they still hold me.
130
:And what about morality?
131
:That's where I started with
the first episode, but just
132
:touching on it a little more.
133
:People often assume that if
you don't believe in God, you
134
:don't believe in goodness.
135
:But for many of us, religion was just the
first place that we encountered values.
136
:Not the only place, not even the
clearest place, but it planted
137
:the early seeds for things like
kindness, responsibility, compassion.
138
:As we grew, we got to question
the soil that those seeds were in.
139
:We got to replant them
somewhere healthier, but the
140
:values, they're still blooming.
141
:I also carried forward the music.
142
:There are still hymns and gospel songs
that I sing or hum along with because
143
:I feel so much when I hear them.
144
:Not because I believe in the words
anymore, but because they remind me of
145
:a time when I felt held, they remind
me of the voices raised in harmony,
146
:of something transcendent, beyond
dogma, beyond doctrine of just awe.
147
:And for me, there's also something
about reverence, about stillness.
148
:Church taught me how to be quiet
with myself and with others.
149
:To be honest, it gave me a sense
that some things are sacred, not
150
:because somebody told me they are,
but because I feel it in my bones.
151
:Nowadays, some people might find it a
little sacrilegious, but I find that
152
:sacredness at the beach, floating
in the sea, watching the sky change.
153
:I've taken the reverence,
but I left the rules.
154
:Another thing that I've taken is
prayer, or at least something like it.
155
:Not petitioning a deity, but just
pausing to speak intention, to ask
156
:questions, to sit with silence.
157
:These days I'm more likely to journal.
158
:I whisper truths to myself in the dark.
159
:Is it prayer?
160
:Probably not in a traditional sense,
but it's definitely a kind of communion.
161
:And I keep saying, maybe that's enough.
162
:Leaving religion didn't mean I
abandoned everything I got from it.
163
:It meant I got to sift through
what it gave me and choose.
164
:Now I can choose to carry
forward what still fits and
165
:bless the rest for what it was.
166
:So I want to ask you now,
what did you take with you?
167
:What ideas or memories still
hold warmth in your chest?
168
:What is your version of sacred?
169
:What do you honor now, not because you
were told to, but because it feels right?
170
:Because walking away
doesn't mean forgetting.
171
:And rejecting the whole house
doesn't mean you can't take
172
:your favorite chair with you.
173
:Of course, not everything
made the journey.
174
:Some things we have to leave behind to
breathe because religion didn't only
175
:give me rhythm or community or memory, it
also gave me messages I had to unlearn.
176
:That's where it gets hard.
177
:So let's talk about what didn't survive.
178
:There was a lot of quiet shame woven
into the framework I grew up with.
179
:There was shame around doubt,
around desire, and especially sex.
180
:It wasn't always spoken about
outright, but you felt it.
181
:You could feel it in the way people
looked at you when you asked the
182
:wrong questions or wore the wrong
clothes or liked the wrong people.
183
:There was a fear-based kind
of goodness expected of us.
184
:Not goodness rooted in love
or understanding, but goodness
185
:driven by the fear of punishment.
186
:Be good or else.
187
:I was a curious kid and I asked a
lot of questions, but eventually
188
:I learned which ones not to ask.
189
:And I think many of us who grew up
in religious environments carried
190
:that fear that curiosity might cost
us belonging or worse, or soul.
191
:I chose to leave that behind, but the
shame is a tough one for many people.
192
:Then we have the binaries, the black
and white thinking that colored
193
:everything that endless either or.
194
:It's right or wrong.
195
:You're saved or damned.
196
:A believer or backslider.
197
:Everything and everyone
is either good or bad.
198
:You were either holy or you were lost.
199
:There was no room for the
messy middle in between.
200
:No space for uncertainty, for
nuance, no space for asking what
201
:if I'm still figuring it out?
202
:It was just a cliff edge and a push.
203
:You were either all in or all out.
204
:You were taught to choose.
205
:Even if that meant choosing
against parts of yourself.
206
:Like many, I learned early how
to split myself into acceptable
207
:fragments, to tuck away the parts
that were too loud, too curious,
208
:too different, to perform certainty
even when I was quietly unraveling.
209
:And the thing about binaries is they make
you afraid of gray, afraid of change,
210
:of holding two things as true at once.
211
:You start to see complexity as weakness.
212
:You believe that doubt is failure, that
if something doesn't fit completely,
213
:it has to be thrown away entirely.
214
:But life doesn't really work like that.
215
:People don't work like that.
216
:When I finally started stepping
away from those binaries, I
217
:didn't just lose a belief system.
218
:I had to relearn how to see the world,
how to hold tension without panicking,
219
:how to trust myself without needing
a label for every single thing.
220
:Honestly, letting go of black and
white thinking didn't make me confused.
221
:It really made me more whole.
222
:But that clarity comes with a cost because
once I started stepping outside of those
223
:lines, I saw just how much of myself
and others I'd been taught to silence.
224
:One of the hardest things
to unlearn was the idea that
225
:being loved meant being small.
226
:That acceptance was conditional and
being accepted meant being silent.
227
:You had to shrink to fit inside
the circle, and you had to
228
:flatten yourself just to be held.
229
:There was a mold, and if you didn't
fit it, the message was clear.
230
:You are the problem, you're the
deviation, you're the danger.
231
:And so for many people, especially
those that are queer or questioning
232
:or complicated in any way or just a
little other, that messaging cuts deep.
233
:The so-called love could sting
because it was love with an asterisk.
234
:Love that said, we accept you as
long as you don't act like yourself.
235
:And that's something that's
very real here in Jamaica.
236
:It's improving, but it's still a problem.
237
:I had to consciously step away
from frameworks that excluded
238
:people I love, from doctrines that
made certain bodies identities
239
:or relationships feel like a sin.
240
:They turned sacred love into something
shameful and continue to see the beautiful
241
:complexity that is humanity as a threat.
242
:And the thing is, it wasn't always loud.
243
:It wasn't always fire and brimstone.
244
:Sometimes that harm came
dressed in kindness.
245
:The exclusion was delivered with a smile,
a gentle tone, a verse and a prayer.
246
:But polite rejection is still rejection.
247
:And once I could name that, I could
begin to loosen the grip that those
248
:messages had on my thoughts, my
mindset, how I saw myself in the world.
249
:Because so much of what we had to
leave behind wasn't just doctrine.
250
:It was the damage those doctrines did
quietly, consistently over time, the
251
:way they shaped how we saw ourselves,
what we believed we deserved, what we
252
:even thought we had to endure to be
worthy of love or belonging or grace.
253
:And naming that can be uncomfortable.
254
:Especially when the harm was
wrapped in familiarity or in love.
255
:But we can't heal what we can't name.
256
:For some people it's fair to
call this religious trauma.
257
:It is not always dramatic or visible.
258
:It's not always headline grabbing.
259
:Sometimes it's just a slow erosion of
self-worth, that deep fear of being wrong,
260
:feeling a lifelong tension between who you
are and who you were told you should be.
261
:And when you start pulling
away from those teachings.
262
:It may not feel like
liberation right away.
263
:It can feel like grief, like exile,
like you're losing the language
264
:you used to make sense of yourself.
265
:For me, letting go did mean
wandering for a while without a map.
266
:I had to face the world without a
script and try to learn to trust
267
:my own compass again, but that's
the work, that's the journey.
268
:So if you're someone who's still in that
in-between space, still figuring out
269
:what you believe, still brushing off the
dust of doctrines that don't fit anymore.
270
:I just want to say, you're
not alone, you're not broken.
271
:So take a breath and ask yourself,
what did you have to leave behind?
272
:What beliefs no longer feel true, even
if once upon a time they felt sacred?
273
:What parts of your old
faith made you shrink?
274
:Not to rehash the pain, but just to
witness yourself and name what no
275
:longer belongs in your hands, because
that's when you can begin to rebuild
276
:something honest, something whole.
277
:Now, the easy story would be
I left and I'm better for it.
278
:And in many ways that's true.
279
:But the fuller story, the
more human one is messier.
280
:Because letting go of religion
doesn't always mean walking away
281
:from everyone who still believes or
from every tradition or every memory
282
:that still stirs something in you.
283
:There are people that I love who
still go to church every Sunday.
284
:Some of them are my family,
some of them are my friends.
285
:They're not villains in my story.
286
:They're part of it, and
sometimes that means biting my
287
:tongue or softening my edges.
288
:Sometimes it means showing up to a
service, not outta faith, but out of love.
289
:And that's okay because the reason
I left and haven't gone back
290
:wasn't to become someone harder.
291
:It was to become someone truer.
292
:But that tension is real.
293
:I've felt it at weddings and
funerals standing quietly during
294
:prayers that I no longer believe in.
295
:Not out of mockery, but out of
memory, out of respect for the
296
:moment, even if not the meaning.
297
:I've felt it when I remain at my seat
when the call for communion is made.
298
:Because I no longer believe in that
symbolism, but I remember the reverence.
299
:And honestly, I remember the taste.
300
:I've felt it during holidays when
the old rituals call up something
301
:inside me that's not quite belief,
but it isn't absence either.
302
:And over the years, I noticed
something interesting.
303
:It's possible to feel
both grief and relief.
304
:To remember the certainty while
still choosing the questioning.
305
:To honor the comfort that religion
once gave you, while also naming,
306
:the harm that it might have caused.
307
:Here's the part I wish
someone had told me earlier.
308
:You don't have to have it all figured
out to start living with intention.
309
:You don't need a label
for everything you feel.
310
:You're allowed to be unfinished.
311
:You don't have to resolve it all.
312
:You don't have to land in a neat category.
313
:You can be a work in progress,
a walking contradiction.
314
:You can be someone who bows their
head at grace and then sits quietly
315
:with their own quiet kind of truth.
316
:It's about choosing
integrity over performance.
317
:Alignment within yourself
over their approval.
318
:And sometimes it's choosing
healing over certainty.
319
:And once we start living that way,
not from fear, but from alignment,
320
:a new question starts to emerge.
321
:If we've stepped away from a faith that
once gave us structure, what holds us now?
322
:If we no longer live by a
divine plan, what do we live by?
323
:Because the truth is we didn't leave
meaning behind, but we're making it new.
324
:Religion gave many of us a script, a
sense that life had a built in purpose.
325
:Follow the rules, honor
God, obey the path.
326
:There is something comforting about
that until it doesn't fit anymore,
327
:until the path narrows and that script
starts to suffocate more than it guides.
328
:When I stepped away from that, there
was a time, maybe a long time where I
329
:felt like I was floating untethered,
like I'd cut the anchor and I
330
:didn't know what else to hold onto.
331
:Because it's not just walking away.
332
:You end up asking, what do I do now?
333
:How do I build a life that's not
defined by what I escaped, but
334
:by what I'm consciously creating?
335
:Over time, I started finding
different roots to hold on to.
336
:Humanist roots, even before
I knew what they were.
337
:Grounded, not in hierarchy,
but in a shared humanity.
338
:Not divine judgment, but mutual care.
339
:Bell hooks once wrote that love is
an action, never simply a feeling.
340
:And I've come to think of
humanism in the same way.
341
:It's not just about what I don't believe
and not even just an idea I believe in.
342
:It's about how I choose to live.
343
:It shows up in how I treat people,
what I protect, what I make
344
:space for, what I choose to love.
345
:So it's not just about rejecting
belief in Gods, it's about
346
:affirming belief in us, in humanity.
347
:It's about choosing to honor the sacred
in a world without a supernatural script
348
:where the sacred isn't handed down, it's
created through care and connection and
349
:responsibility through love as action.
350
:Now meaning looks different.
351
:It's not handed down.
352
:It's built layer by
layer through intention.
353
:And my purpose comes from within, from
the pull of curiosity, from the work
354
:that makes me feel useful from the
moments when I show up fully in my
355
:own life and in the lives of others.
356
:Relationships have become sacred, not
because somebody says so from the pulpit.
357
:But because love is a kind of
miracle and holding space for someone
358
:else's truth is downright holy work.
359
:Responsibility is my compass now.
360
:It's not fear of eternal consequences,
but caring about the real world ones.
361
:What I do matters because
it impacts others.
362
:Because this life, it's what I've got
and how I live, it ripples outwards.
363
:This is what I mean when I say no gods,
no guilt, just the work of being human.
364
:It's not perfect.
365
:It's not always certain.
366
:But it's real, deliberate and alive.
367
:And I want to leave you with
this thought that you don't
368
:have to borrow meaning anymore.
369
:You can build it.
370
:And maybe the best place to start
building is by pausing, by turning
371
:inward, asking the quiet questions
that help you see what's still shaping
372
:you and what you're ready to reshape.
373
:So let's take a breath.
374
:I want to leave you with
some space to reflect.
375
:No pressure, no performance.
376
:Just a quiet invitation to turn inward.
377
:Take a moment this week.
378
:Ask yourself, what parts of your
religious upbringing still live in you?
379
:Was it the music, the rituals, the
values, the voices, what still echoes?
380
:Which parts have you lovingly released?
381
:Maybe it's the fear, the shame.
382
:What have you let fall away,
not with anger, but with grace?
383
:And maybe the hardest question,
if you're not there yet,
384
:but start to think about it.
385
:How do you want to define your
moral and spiritual compass now?
386
:Not the one you inherited,
but the one you're building.
387
:If you're interested in taking it even
deeper, here's a journal exercise for you.
388
:Write a letter, a thank you and goodbye
letter to your childhood religion.
389
:Tell it what it gave you.
390
:Tell it what it took.
391
:Tell it what you are
reclaiming for yourself.
392
:You don't have to share it.
393
:You don't even have to read it again.
394
:Just write it for the sake of
clarity, for the sake of peace.
395
:If anything in this episode stirred
something in you, a memory, a question,
396
:a story of your own, I'd love to hear it.
397
:You can send me a voice note
or write in anonymously, email
398
:is hello@livegoodwalkgood.com
399
:or via any of our social channels.
400
:I may share a few reflections
in future episodes.
401
:Always with consent, so let me
know when you submit, if you're
402
:okay with it being shared.
403
:Because these aren't just
my stories, they're ours.
404
:And maybe, in hearing some of
our stories, you've started
405
:remembering more of your own.
406
:The detours, the doubts, the quiet shifts
that you couldn't name at the time.
407
:And maybe you didn't walk a
straight line out of religion.
408
:Maybe it was more like wandering
or wrestling, or slowly loosening
409
:your grip as you tried to let go.
410
:And maybe there's still a part of you
holding tension between who you were
411
:taught to be and who you're becoming now.
412
:And that's okay.
413
:You don't have to hate your
past to grow beyond it.
414
:You don't have to discard every single
memory to step into a new kind of meaning.
415
:You can honor what was
while choosing what is.
416
:Next time, we'll go deeper into
what that choice looks like for me.
417
:We'll look at what is humanism
anyway, and why is it more
418
:than just not believing in God?
419
:We'll talk about values, purpose,
and how to build a life rooted
420
:in compassion and clarity without
needing a supernatural framework.
421
:So you're welcome to join me
for that in our next episode.
422
:Until then...
423
:live good, walk good.